|
|
Dr. Kaman Singh Designation: Reader Branch: Physical Chemistry Specialization: Solid State Chemistry Spectroscopy Electrochemistry Material Science Sugar Colorimetry Date of Birth: December 21, 1965 Residence: 11 Readers’ Flat, Faizabad Road Babuganj, Lucknow - 226007 Phone: 941-540-9189 email: drkamansingh@yahoo.com
Academics
Professional Training
Employment
Honors
Memberships
Recent Publications
Review Articles
Projects in Hand
ICUMSA* (ESTD: 1897)
It is an
International Organization solely concerned with the analytical methods for
sugar analysis for the world sugar trade. Today it has a history of over 100
years and its parameters are strictly followed by the esteemed organizations
like ISO, WTO, Codex Alimentarius Commission (FAO & WHO) and Food and Sugar
Market Legislations of various countries. ICUMSA organizes its Meet every 2
years (previously 4 yrs) in one of its member country. India is also a member
country of this esteemed organization. This year, it has organized its 26th
session in Florida (USA) from 1st to 3rd October 2008.
At pH = 7.0 the colour of WHITE SUGAR should
be < 50 ICUMSA unit
For Indian Plantation White Sugar colour
should be < 150 ICUMSA Unit
FACT FILE OF SUGAR STANDARD DEVELOPMENT
1.
1954-1978: Only one Official method for measuring sugar quality at its
own pH (No pH adjustment by adding any buffer chemical).
2.
1978- However, at the Montreal Session of the ICUMSA (1978) a
recommendation was proposed that sugar solution should be standardized at pH 7.0
prior to quality determination. Subsequently a decision to change the method was
taken up at the 20th ICUMSA session (Colorado, 1990) using TEA buffer
(pH 7.0). Since then, topic has received interest.
3.
2002: pH-standard at pH 7.0 using TEA buffers was accorded official
Status for world sugar trade. Subsequently, when Indian sugar was tested,
it revealed that colour increases by 30% of the colour value recorded at its
“natural pH of 6.4 to 6.5”. It puts Indian sugar at disadvantage in
international market. Indian National Committee opposed this nefarious effort of
which I have also been a member from the last 6 years.
4.
8-9 April 2004 (Atalanta Agreement): The nefarious and unscientific
effort to dissolve sugars in buffers at pH 7.0 was discarded. Instead, a New
Buffer (MOPS) at pH 7.0 was introduced and sugar was divided into two separate
commodities. Consequently, a separate Subject (GS-9) was created for Indian
Sugar within ICUMSA that leaded inferiority of Indian sugar over other sugar
products and considerable loss of National premium. Before this, PMWS was
considered as WHITE SUGAR.
5.
2004: I personally challenged Atalanta Agreement through New Years
Greeting Card 2004 entitled “THE POLITICS OF pH”.
6.
Impact of Arbitrary pH 7.0 on Quality of Indian Sugar
(i)
Indian sugar can not be considered as “White Sugar”
(ii)
Indian sugar will not be able to complete in “International Market”.
(iii)
It cannot be considered suitable for use in “soft drinks”.
(iv)
It cannot be considered suitable for use in many “food products’
Thus, it
is evident to deteriorate the prospectus of Indian sugar in the global market.
7.
24 November 2004: Aggrieved by this resolution that prima facie
appears contradictory to the scientific spirit and completely based on arbitrary
foundations I appealed to the Honorable ICUMSA President Prof Vaccari,
advocating for the standardization of pH for quality analysis method at the
NATURAL pH of extreme quality (99.98% pure) sugar, i.e., 6.4, that affirms the
scientific basis. The details of the scientific basis how to arrive at actual pH
of 6.4 have been published in International Journals (Eight major publications
in the relevant field).
8.
December 3, 2004: The Honorable ICUMSA President Prof Vaccari
forwarded my letter to all the Referees involved in this problem so that they
could deicide the inclusion of my views in Referees Reports to be presented at
the next sessions of ICUMSA (Brazil 2006).
9.
April 2006: The General Secretary of the ICUMSA Dr. Hanjo Puke mailed
a letter to Indian National Committee (INC) of ICUMSA in connection with my
correspondence to ICUMSA Secretariat.
10.
27th April, 2006:
The INC took the cognizance of Dr. Puke’s letter and my Membership was
terminated with immediate effect without any justification at all. The
version of the Proceedings is being reproduced herewith:-
Dear
Sir,
As you
are an Member of the ICUMSA National Committee on ICUMSA and you had been told
in several meetings in the past that as a member of the Indian National
committee you are not supposed to address communication to ICUMSA head office
directly. In the past you had done so and you were informed by the Hon’ble
secretary vide his letter dt. That you are not supposed to do the same. It has
been observed that persistently you have been violating this protocol to a very
disrepute by your latest letter and even the specially designed greeting card
that you sent to the President ICUMSA and other experts of ICUMSA. You are
perhaps aware that Dr. Puke has taken a very serious objection to your letter
and he has circulated the same to all the colleagues in ICUMSA. Below is the
letter of Dr. Puke reproduced for your information.”
“In a scientific
community, everybody should have the right to express his point of view on a
certain scientific question. This has always been a principle of our work in
ICUMSA and therefore, it seems to be necessary to give Prof. Kaman Singh the
opportunity to present his opinion on pH and on determination of colour in
solution of sugar. However, the ICUMSA Session cannot be a platform to fight out
animosities existing within the INC.
Prof. Singh has
expressed his pointy of view already in his letter to Prof. Vaccari on 24th
November 2004 (Enclosure). This letter, however, and as well his “Christmas
Card” on the “Politics of pH” (Enclosure), seam to indicate, that he does not
intend to discuss new aspects of the Atlanta Meeting, but that he wants toexpand
his aggression against Dr. Keskar to our whole organization (Dr. Keskar’s
comment enclosed). To my opinion, the arguing of Prof. Singh gives no reason to
reiterate the discussion on adjustment of pH in colour determination, and we
should carefully consider the usefulness of his presentation. Please let me know
your opinion.
Best regards.
Hanjo Puke”
NOTICE SERVED
BY THE SECRETARY OF THE STAI (INC) AS FOLLOWING TO Dr. PUKE’S LETTER
“YOU WILL
NOTE FROM THAT IT IS A VERY DISGRACEFUL MATTER AND IT HAS BROUGHT DOWN THE
REPUTATION OF THE INC. IN VIEW OF YOUR PERSISTENT VIOLATION OF CODE OF CONDUCT
AND PROTOCOL, THE COMMITTEE HAS DECIDED TO TERMINATE YOUR MEMBERSHIP OF THE
NATIONAL COMMITTEE, WHICH DECISION, I DO HEREBY COMMUNICATE TO YOU. PLEASE NOTE”
11.
17 May, 2006: I requested to Hon’ble Minister for Consumer Affairs, Food
and Public Distribution, Honorable Shri Sharad Pawar Ji with a request to look
into this sensitive issue in entirety keeping in view the best interest of our
country in the field of sugar.
12.
27 August 2006: I re-appealed to ICUMSA Secretariat and Honorable
Referees of the ICUMSA about scientific proposal for fixation of Standard at pH
= 6.4. Many Referees responded to my proposal.
13.
Sept 9-11, 2006: The INC requested me to present my views at its Meeting
held on Sept 9-11, 2006 at New Delhi. I conceived that this happened as a
consequence of my correspondence to Honorable Shri Sharad Pawar Ji, Hon’ble
Minister for Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, Govt. of India.
14.
Sept 20-22, 2006: The INC on
ICUMSA decided to make a presentation based on my Research Proposal
“SELECTION OF pH FOR MEASUREMENT OF SUGAR SOLUTION COLOUR” at 25th
ICUMSA Meeting (Brazil) and the same was presented Officially at Brazil Session
of the ICUMSA (Sept 20-22, 2006).
15.
October10, 2006: The INC reinstated my membership to INC of ICUMSA.
Since, as per the
IUPAC-1989 Protocol, for the acceptance of any new method proposed, results have
to be authenticated by analyzing the reports of the tests conducted at least in
six different laboratories. I made repeated requests to the INC President and
Convenor to comply with the IUPAC Protocol, but no response was given to my
request, thus, I personally initiated the process at my own expenses and
conducted the test in 6 labs across the country and accumulated the results,
which found to be concurrent and very satisfactory. A comprehensive report based
on the acquired data was Officially presented by me at the 26th
ICUMSA Meeting held at Florida from October 1 to 3, 2008. The Report has been
very well received by the attendees.
Sir, this is perhaps
the first time in the History of ICUMSA that the Poster paper have allowed to
present Orally and Officially at the concluding session of the ICUMSA Meeting.
After my presentation, the Hon’ble President Mr. Parkin asked for any COMMENT or
OBJECTION. In fact, there was a pin drop silence; no comment or no objection
came from any corner. But Mr. Parkin opined that many National Committee members
are not present, hence, final decision could not be possible right now. Then, I
appealed to the President that we wanted at least an assurance from ICUMSA for
further future course of action like INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATIVE TEST for its
OFFICIAL STATUS and then he asked for Recommendation from the Referee. Then, the
Subject Referee made a Recommendation for International Collaborative Test on my
Proposal. The President Mr. Parkin further directed Dr. Bruns (The Publisher of
Bartens) for publication of my presentation in toto in ICUMSA Proceedings. I
hope, this would lead to generate New Dimensions in the world sugar trade.
MAJOR ACHIEVEMENTS
1.
ICUMSA ultimately got
convinced and my proposal to fix standard at pH 6.4 for sugar quality
determination has been ACCEPTED FOR INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATIVE STUDY (ICS).
2.
The findings will be placed before next session of ICUMSA (New Orleans,
2010) for its OFFICIAL STATUS.
OVERALL IMPACT ON INDIAN SUGAR
INDUSTRY
(i)
Indian sugar will be considered as “White Sugar” against “raw sugar” as
considered today in the International market.
(ii)
Indian sugar will be able to compete in “International Market”.
(iii)
It can be considered suitable for use in “soft drinks”.
(iv)
It can be considered suitable for use in many “food products
|
|
|
| ||
|
Copyright Department of Chemistry, University of Lucknow, Lucknow
Website Developed and Maintained by:
Dr. Anil
Mishra,
Department of Chemistry, University of
Lucknow, Lucknow |
||
|
|
||